Yeah hopefully Raww will be around And okPyriel wrote:If you're this interested in determining whether or not it works in a particular version, why wouldn't you try it a few times? It'd take like 5 minutes. Find a stat stone, save, check your stats, use the stone, go out and die, "Don't Give Up", check your stats, and repeat. You say you don't "think" it worked. Well, write a few things down and confirm it. Take a picture or two, if you can manage it. We'll all thank you when Raww can add an errata section to his article and correct the record.
Bug Fixes
- suikokid2
- Posts: 30
- Joined: Wed Dec 21, 2016 5:33 am
Re: Bug Fixes
- suikokid2
- Posts: 30
- Joined: Wed Dec 21, 2016 5:33 am
Re: Bug Fixes
Btw one thing i dont understand, if stat stone trick isnt in the PSP version why would konami and suikosource say it is?Pyriel wrote:If you're this interested in determining whether or not it works in a particular version, why wouldn't you try it a few times? It'd take like 5 minutes. Find a stat stone, save, check your stats, use the stone, go out and die, "Don't Give Up", check your stats, and repeat. You say you don't "think" it worked. Well, write a few things down and confirm it. Take a picture or two, if you can manage it. We'll all thank you when Raww can add an errata section to his article and correct the record.
- Pyriel
- Webmaster
- Posts: 1232
- Joined: Wed Aug 18, 2004 1:20 pm
Re: Bug Fixes
I don't think Konami ever said it was there. Developers and publishers usually don't make claims like that unless it's something they're putting in the ads or on the box. I guess it could be in the instruction manual, or in a guide if one was published for this version. I doubt it, though. That is, it wasn't in the manual for the PS version, so it'd be weird to document the feature ten years later. And I very much doubt they'd have done anything other than re-release the PS guide, assuming there was one, and they felt like a re-release would sell.
I don't think it's explicitly stated on this site that the stat stones are exploitable. The exploit probably wasn't checked because it didn't seem particularly important, and it's just taken as implicit that it's still there because the guide says, "no bugs aside from the Matilda Glitch were fixed," or words to that effect. We don't even know that implying it's there is false yet, because nobody has done the work to confirm.
As to how such a theoretical mistake could have been made, well, not many people in the West were that interested in this remake, and similarly few people have your weird, laser-focus on getting correct information about a trivial mechanic in a remake that maybe a few hundred people outside Japan have played. That focus would be admirable, if it didn't also involve constantly harassing other people to develop the information for you.
I don't think it's explicitly stated on this site that the stat stones are exploitable. The exploit probably wasn't checked because it didn't seem particularly important, and it's just taken as implicit that it's still there because the guide says, "no bugs aside from the Matilda Glitch were fixed," or words to that effect. We don't even know that implying it's there is false yet, because nobody has done the work to confirm.
As to how such a theoretical mistake could have been made, well, not many people in the West were that interested in this remake, and similarly few people have your weird, laser-focus on getting correct information about a trivial mechanic in a remake that maybe a few hundred people outside Japan have played. That focus would be admirable, if it didn't also involve constantly harassing other people to develop the information for you.
-
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Fri Dec 12, 2014 3:47 am
Re: Bug Fixes
So how many of these bugs were in the original Japanese version?
-
- Posts: 324
- Joined: Wed Feb 13, 2013 11:48 am
Re: Bug Fixes
Basically all of them, except the music-related errors. Those are only available in the US release.
- Pyriel
- Webmaster
- Posts: 1232
- Joined: Wed Aug 18, 2004 1:20 pm
Re: Bug Fixes
There are a few more exceptions, but music is the big one that Japan didn't get.
- In the US version only, there are lines of dialogue missing for Gremio in Banner Village that cause gibberish text at best, and crashes at worst.
- In the US version only, the Suikoden name values (hero and castle) are copied over incorrectly.
- In the US version only, a good many audio tracks, including music and sound effects, will not play because of an issue when the disc was mastered.
- The Tinto Glitch is not present in the Japanese version, as it's (likely) due to an area module being cloned when it got too large during localization. I think the issue is present in the European versions as well, but I can't recall if I did any work to confirm it. It may only be in certain versions. It depends on whether or not a specific localization effort caused the original module to grow beyond the 300KB limit.
- There are two bugs in the German version that involve a "blank" option being added to event choices. If I remember correctly, one is during the Two River battle, and it's a blank line below the "Fight!" options. The other is in Gregminster when you first visit. These are localization issues that I believe are due to line lengths and the weird ways choices can be specified in dialogue and menus.
- This isn't really a bug, but translation issues abound. Obviously there are no translation problems in the Japanese game, but they're numerous and vary wildly in the western versions. In the US, we get untranslated text all over the place, lines that seem out of place, cats that say, "Sonya," and so on. The UK version has the translation mostly completed, but retains the bulk of the other problems. Meanwhile the German version has arguably the worst translation, with simple mistakes like, "chain mail/armor," being translated to, "chain letter," all over the place.
Last edited by Pyriel on Tue Jun 27, 2017 11:00 am, edited 2 times in total.
-
- Posts: 2806
- Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2008 9:48 am
- Location: Germany, yeah baby
- Contact:
Re: Bug Fixes
Just to correct something, while sometimes nonsensical, the German translation was at least German. I remember a Spanish fan talking about the Spanish translation and at times, he didn't know whether the game was Spanish or Italian (probably neither). Bottomline - all European translations of the game are probably among the worst localizations of JRPGs ever.
But the German version introduced two game crashing bugs, so yeah, not so hot.
But the German version introduced two game crashing bugs, so yeah, not so hot.
- Pyriel
- Webmaster
- Posts: 1232
- Joined: Wed Aug 18, 2004 1:20 pm
Re: Bug Fixes
Oh yeah, I forgot about those.
And all the Romance translations probably used Esperanto whenever something was in doubt.
And all the Romance translations probably used Esperanto whenever something was in doubt.
- suikokid2
- Posts: 30
- Joined: Wed Dec 21, 2016 5:33 am
Re: Bug Fixes
Stats glitch is there....Pyriel wrote:I don't think Konami ever said it was there. Developers and publishers usually don't make claims like that unless it's something they're putting in the ads or on the box. I guess it could be in the instruction manual, or in a guide if one was published for this version. I doubt it, though. That is, it wasn't in the manual for the PS version, so it'd be weird to document the feature ten years later. And I very much doubt they'd have done anything other than re-release the PS guide, assuming there was one, and they felt like a re-release would sell.
I don't think it's explicitly stated on this site that the stat stones are exploitable. The exploit probably wasn't checked because it didn't seem particularly important, and it's just taken as implicit that it's still there because the guide says, "no bugs aside from the Matilda Glitch were fixed," or words to that effect. We don't even know that implying it's there is false yet, because nobody has done the work to confirm.
As to how such a theoretical mistake could have been made, well, not many people in the West were that interested in this remake, and similarly few people have your weird, laser-focus on getting correct information about a trivial mechanic in a remake that maybe a few hundred people outside Japan have played. That focus would be admirable, if it didn't also involve constantly harassing other people to develop the information for you.
http://suikosource.com/games/gs2/secrets/
-
- Posts: 2806
- Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2008 9:48 am
- Location: Germany, yeah baby
- Contact:
Re: Bug Fixes
Pyriel was talking about stat stones in the PSP remake.
- suikokid2
- Posts: 30
- Joined: Wed Dec 21, 2016 5:33 am
Re: Bug Fixes
I was just showing it is listed on the site.
-
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Tue Jun 27, 2017 4:06 pm
Re: Bug Fixes
I've been playing with the Bug Fix patch, and I might have come across a problem.... In order to defeat Rowd, I saved before meeting Nanami and continued the game without saving until I casually pushed aside the gate leading to Rockaxe. Obviously, I didn't apply that part of the patch. I went up a few levels before getting a Game Over and Retrying. I had received 1 or 2 one-time-only items from encounters. Seed Potato was one I'm sure I got. However... I've been trying to get these items again, but they aren't showing up. I no longer have them because of the Game Over, so I should be able to get them again, right? I've received about 10 or so Thunder Amulets from the ZombieSlugs, but no Recipe #29. Any idea what's going on here?
-
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Tue Jun 27, 2017 4:06 pm
Re: Bug Fixes
Nevermind. Apparently I got Recipe #29 and Sound Set #2 and forgot about it. So it's only the Seed Potato that I can't get. I'll keep trying. Just disregard my previous post.
- Pyriel
- Webmaster
- Posts: 1232
- Joined: Wed Aug 18, 2004 1:20 pm
Re: Bug Fixes
For what it's worth, the bug fix patch only has an effect if you give the collectibles to their respective people in the castle. When an item is just sitting in your inventory, none of the bug fixes address anything to do with that. If for some reason you can't get the potato seed again, it would probably be due to either bad luck, or a previously undiscovered bug of some kind.
-
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Tue Jun 27, 2017 4:06 pm
Re: Bug Fixes
Yeah, sorry, I shouldn't have jumped to conclusions so soon. I don't know why I was so convinced I had found some kind of bug. That was a bit uncharacteristic of me.
On another note... the amount of spelling and grammar errors is astounding! I had forgotten just how badly localized this game was. Reminds me of Lufia: The Legend Returns. I wonder if anyone will ever attempt to fix the script? I can't help but screen shot the hilariously bad parts. lol
And one last thing: It was either in this thread or the Game Shark codes thread where it was mentioned that characters have lines that are impossible to see in normal play. I would like to add (if I'm in the right thread) that Humphrey and Futch have lines in many different situations well before they are supposed to be recruited. So it's likely true that way more was written than what was used. This game is a masterpiece in many ways.
On another note... the amount of spelling and grammar errors is astounding! I had forgotten just how badly localized this game was. Reminds me of Lufia: The Legend Returns. I wonder if anyone will ever attempt to fix the script? I can't help but screen shot the hilariously bad parts. lol
And one last thing: It was either in this thread or the Game Shark codes thread where it was mentioned that characters have lines that are impossible to see in normal play. I would like to add (if I'm in the right thread) that Humphrey and Futch have lines in many different situations well before they are supposed to be recruited. So it's likely true that way more was written than what was used. This game is a masterpiece in many ways.