Well I dont know why you people get so serious about it.
Is not a problem to me if someone wishes to see a dead character again... or the opposite.I think both opinions are to respected.
Anyway (To me) troy was not that important but, to the people that say a dead character is dead I'd tell you to remember that if two guys leaving a castle falling to pieces managed to survive I dont see a problem in surviving a sinking ship.
I think we should be realistic.If konami people want Troy back, or Gremio becoming his servant because young master mc dohl has left him, or even a talking dog as main character
so will be, cause they have last word.