I had forgotten about that part but there was still the other half of the argument when I said it would have been better to let sonya come to them.
And again, why would Sonya come out of her fortress...?
You can't just do nothing during the war. Why would she stay in there? She would have to make a move at some point.
The story didn't say that she was in her fort because she was scared or wanted a defensive advantage. She was in her fort because the Liberation army was on the offensive.
Why she didn't come out of her fortress? who knows. Technicly within the game itself the game only took place in the course of about half a year. We're only told later through developer commentary that its been 2 years.
The point is that shes in a war you don't just do nothing in a war.
What if Barbossa had been killed already? what if they cut the supplies to the fortress and forced everyone to starve to death. I doubt they had the forsite or land to start a farm in their castle. Tir on the otherhand had land on his island and 2 farmers. (though one was technicly a gardner.)
Sonya's army count not have been self sufficant because of how big her fortress was to the island she was on.
Cut supplies or force her to attack.
I'm a fan but I'm also a critic. Without preasure to improve stagnation is the future. Do not accept lackluster because of your enjoyment of the overall picture. Criticism is needed for improvement to be made.